OK, the list is in. Points were calculated as 1pt for MSP foals, 3pts for SW foals, and 5pts for MSW foals. The top 10 are as follows:

Sires:

1. Highland Rogue - 77 foals, 74 racers, 10 MSPs, 10 SWs, 19 MSWs - **135 points**

2. What's It Worth - 102 foals, 50 racers, 5 MSPs, 9 SWs, 19 MSWs - **127 points**

3. Planet Hollywood - 86 foals, 47 racers, 7 MSPs, 5 SWs, 7 MSWs - **57 points**

4. Rainbow Quest - 49 foals, 27 racers, 3 MSPs, 2 SWs, 9 MSWs - **54 points**

5. A.P. Indy - 69 foals, 32 racers, 2 MSPs, 2 SWs, 9 MSWs - **53 points**

6. Cross Roads - 68 foals, 36 racers, 3 MSPs, 3 SWs, 7 MSWs - **47 points**

7. Cigar - 48 foals, 23 racers, 1 MSP, 4 SWs, 5 MSWs - **38 points**

8. Lucky Cigar - 49 foals, 36 racers, 4 MSPs, 1 SW, 5 MSWs - **32 points**

9. Secretariat - 50 foals, 18 racers, 0 MSPs, 2 SWs, 5 MSWs - **31 points**

10. Lonesome Glory - 46 foals, 17 racers, 5 MSPs, 5 SWs, 2 MSWs - **30 points**

Grandsires:

1. Highland Rogue - 295 foals, 63 racers, 3 MSPs, 10 SWs, 18 MSWs - **123 points**

2. Seattle Slew - 165 foals, 88 racers, 8 MSPs, 7 SWs, 11 MSWs - **84 points**

3. Secretariat - 107 foals, 38 racers, 1 MSP, 4 SWs, 7 MSWs - **48 points**

4. Bold Ruler - 70 foals, 25 racers, 1 MSP, 2 SWs, 6 MSWs - **37 points**

5. Cigar - 71 foals, 41 racers, 5 MSPs, 2 SWs, 5 MSWs - **36 points**

6. Alydar - 62 foals, 19 racers, 0 MSPs, 0 SWs, 5 MSWs - **25 points**

7. Northern Dancer - 42 foals, 11 racers, 1 MSP, 1 SW, 4 MSWs - **24 points**

8. Mr. Prospector - 68 foals, 47 racers, 1 MSP, 3 SWs, 2 MSWs - **20 points**

9. The Black - 14 foals, 4 racers, 0 MSPs, 0 SWs, 3 MSWs - **15 points**

10. Man O'War - 42 foals, 15 racers, 0 MSP, 1 SW, 2 MSWs - **13 points**

Broodmare sires:

1. Highland Rogue - 111 foals, 37 racers, 3 MSPs, 7 SW, 12 MSWs - **84 points**

2. Seattle Slew - 42 foals, 22 racers, 3 MSPs, 4 SWs, 2 MSWs - **25 points**

3. Mr. Prospector - 32 foals, 18 racers, 1 MSP, 3 SWs, 2 MSWs - **20 points**

4. Secretariat - 23 foals, 10 racers, 0 MSPs, 2 SWs, 2 MSWs - **16 points**

5. The Black - 14 foals, 4 racers, 0 MSPs, 0 SWs, 3 MSWs - **15 points**

6. Spectacular Bid - 12 foals, 4 racers, 1 MSP, 0 SWs, 2 MSWs - **11 points**

7. Whirlaway - 22 foals, 9 racers, 0 MSPs, 2 SWs, 1 MSW - **11 points**

8. Count Fleet - 14 foals, 7 racers, 0 MSPs, 0 SWs, 2 MSWs - **10 points**

9. Dixieland Jazz - 10 foals, 2 racers, 0 MSPs, 0 SWs, 2 MSWs - **10 points**

10. Affirmed - 9 foals, 6 racers, 0 MSPs, 1 SW, 1 MSW - **8 points**

Basically the only horses that make all 3 lists are Highland Rogue and Secretariat.

Comments? Suggestions for a "final" list of chef-de-race sires?

(Obviously as time goes on more sires could qualify, but for now, we need something to start with.)